WASHINGTON – Ninety-five bishops from President Bush’s church, including four from Maryland, said they repent their “complicity” in the “unjust and immoral” invasion and occupation of Iraq.
“In the face of the United States administration’s rush toward military action based on misleading information, too many of us were silent,” said a statement of conscience signed by more than half of the 164 retired and active United Methodist bishops worldwide.
President Bush is a member of the United Methodist Church, according to various published biographies. The White House did not return a request for comment on the bishops’ statement.
The current bishop for the Baltimore-Washington area, John R. Schol, signed, as did retired bishops James K. Mathews of Bethesda, Joseph H. Yeakel of Smithsburg and Forrest C. Stith of Upper Marlboro.
Although United Methodist leadership has opposed the Iraq war in the past, this is the first time that individual bishops have confessed to a personal failure to publicly challenge the buildup to the war.
The signatures were also an instrument for retired bishops to make their views known, said Yeakel, who served in the Baltimore-Washington area from 1984 to 1996.
The statement avoids making accusations, said retired Bishop Kenneth L. Carder, instructor at Duke University’s divinity school and an author of the document.
“We would have made the statement regardless of who the president was. It was not meant to be either partisan or to single out any one person,” Carder said. “It was the recognition that we are all part of the decision and we are all part of a democratic society. We all bear responsibility.”
Stith, who spent more than three years after his retirement working in East Africa — including with Rwandan refugees — said going to war over the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks did not solve the real problems behind them.
The real issues are that much of the world lives in poverty, desperation and depression, he said, while an affluent minority of the world often oppresses them. Americans need to take responsibility for their world, Stith said.
“To ignore things and to assume that persons in the government have all knowledge is to reject our franchise and our democracy,” Stith said.
About six weeks ago, Carder discussed the idea of a public statement with other colleagues who “had concerns” about the war, and the idea just grew, Carder said.
Last week, the statement circulated during a biannual meeting of the Council of Bishops, “and before the week was out, we had 95 bishops,” Carder said.
In their statement, the bishops pledged to pray daily for the end of the war, for its American and Iraqi victims and for American leaders to find “truth, humility and policies of peace through justice.”
“We confess our preoccupation with institutional enhancement and limited agendas while American men and women are sent to Iraq to kill and be killed, while thousands of Iraqi people needlessly suffer and die, while poverty increases and preventable diseases go untreated,” the statement said.
Some bishops declined to sign their names, although they supported the statement, Carder said.
This week’s statement follows years of public opposition to the Iraq war by the church.
In May 2004, the Council of Bishops passed a resolution that “lamented the continued warfare” and asked the U.S. government to seek international help to rebuild Iraq. The church’s women’s division called for an end to the war in 2002. And in 2001, the church’s head of social policy, Jim Winkler, said the push for war was “without any justification according to the teachings of Christ,” according to a report by The (London) Observer.
Public approval of the war has steadily declined since the United States invaded Iraq in March 2003. At the time, seven of 10 Americans said the U.S. did the right thing. By this October, only four of 10 Americans did, according to CBS polls.
Only 25 percent of Marylanders approve of the war, according to an October poll by Gonzales Marketing and Research Strategies.
About 11 million people belong to the United Methodist Church, including 200,000 in the Baltimore-Washington area.
Carder and Stith said they hoped their statement would encourage more people to think about peacemaking.
“The only solution seems to be to stay the course. But if you’re on the wrong course, you don’t stay the course,” Carder said. “At the heart of the Christian faith is the willingness to acknowledge mistakes.”